How My Neighbor Stole Christmas Book Summary

In the festive town of Kringletown, Cole Black, a Christmas grump haunted by the loss of his parents, avoids the season’s cheer at all costs. Meanwhile, Storee Taylor reluctantly returns to Kringle with her sister, Taran, to care for their aunt Cindy. When Storee is entered into the annual Christmas Kringle competition as Cindy’s proxy, she faces not only holiday chaos but also a head-to-head rivalry with Cole, who unexpectedly joins the contest to challenge her.

The competition features whimsical events—from Eggnog Wars to Upcycle Christmas and Candy Cane Showdowns—where Storee and Cole’s rivalry flares. Their sarcastic banter and schemes escalate as they sabotage each other’s efforts, yet underneath the rivalry, a growing connection begins to emerge. Storee finds herself drawn to Cole’s vulnerability, especially as she learns about his tragic past, while Cole is unexpectedly warmed by Storee’s presence and her willingness to embrace Kringle’s charm.

As the competition intensifies, so does their relationship. The two share tender and passionate moments, from working together during a snowstorm to decorating Cole’s home for the first time since his parents’ death. Both confront their fears and loneliness, realizing how much they’ve been missing in their lives. However, their fragile connection is tested when Cole’s Christmas lights are mysteriously sabotaged. Believing Storee betrayed him to win, Cole retreats into heartbreak and anger.

The truth emerges when Taran confesses she dismantled Cole’s display, mistakenly thinking she was protecting her sister. Desperate to make amends, Storee rallies the entire town to restore Cole’s lights. In a grand, heartfelt gesture, Storee confesses her love for Cole, proving her sincerity and determination to repair the damage.

In the final scene, Cole realizes his mistrust was misplaced. Moved by Storee’s efforts and heartfelt confession, he admits his love for her. Together, they embrace under the glow of restored Christmas lights, rekindling not only their love but also Cole’s long-buried joy for the holiday season. The story concludes with the two setting aside rivalry, celebrating Christmas together, and embracing the magic of love, community, and second chances.

How My Neighbor Stole Christmas Chapter by Chapter Book Summary

Prologue Summary

In the town of Kringletown, everyone celebrated Christmas with great enthusiasm—everyone except for Cole Black, who lived on Whistler Lane and despised the festive season. While townsfolk speculated on the reasons for his disdain, such as his single status or being overlooked as the "Town Kringle," the truth lay in the sorrow of losing both his parents when he was eighteen. Since then, Cole had withdrawn, avoiding all things Christmas while glaring from his dark, undecorated home at the cheerful holiday displays and townspeople.

As the season approached, Cole braced himself for the annual Kringletown tradition of naming the "Town Kringle," a festive contest he dismissed as meaningless. However, his usual grumpy routine was disrupted when he noticed a familiar red-haired woman arriving in town with luggage. Recognizing her from years ago, Cole grew uneasy, determined to uncover why she had returned—and to find a way to prevent her from staying through the Christmas season.

Chapter 1 Summary

Storee Taylor and her older sister, Taran, arrive in Kringletown, Colorado, at their Aunt Cindy’s pink Victorian house to help care for her after a hip injury. Storee humorously narrates the chilly arrival, playfully complaining about the cold weather and her dynamic with Taran, who is practical and uptight. The trip to Kringletown was prompted by a chaotic family meeting, where their parents, vacationing in Cancún, delegated the responsibility of caregiving to Storee and Taran.

Storee reflects on her past Christmas visits to Aunt Cindy’s house, recalling the warmth and festive decorations that once defined the home. However, upon entering, she is shocked to find the house devoid of holiday cheer—no decorations, no tree, and no signs of Christmas magic. Taran explains the absence, attributing it to Aunt Cindy’s inability to decorate after her injury.

The sisters begin settling into the house. Taran declares she will stay in the larger, cozier "red room," leaving Storee to face her childhood fear of the "nightmare room," filled with eerie American Girl dolls meticulously arranged in lifelike dioramas. Storee vividly recalls her childhood terror of the dolls, recounting an incident where she believed one winked at her, leading to a broken wrist.

As they prepare for Aunt Cindy’s return, Storee unsuccessfully tries to negotiate switching rooms with Taran. Despite her reluctance, Storee accepts her role in helping Aunt Cindy, but her sense of unease about the dolls and her playful sibling rivalry with Taran set the tone for the challenges ahead. The chapter concludes with the sisters beginning to unpack and settle into what promises to be an eventful holiday season.

Chapter 2 Summary

The chapter opens with Cole Black, a Kringletown local, grumpily processing the news of the Taylor sisters’ arrival. Gossip spreads quickly through the small town, but Cole is particularly irritated by Storee’s return, recalling an unresolved history between them. While talking to his best friend Max at the Evergreen Farm, where he works caring for reindeer, Cole deflects Max’s teasing about his apparent lingering interest in Storee. Cole insists he has no intention of interacting with her during her stay.

Kringletown, a year-round Christmas town, is described as a bustling hub of festive activities. Cole finds solace in the solitude of his reindeer barn and his routine, avoiding the town’s constant cheer. However, his attempt to steer clear of Storee fails when they cross paths at Kringle Krampus, the local deli.

The encounter starts with Storee mistakenly calling him "Connor," an intentional jab that reignites their familiar banter. Storee's playful teasing and Cole's irritation escalate into a back-and-forth exchange, mirroring their interactions from a decade ago. Cole remembers their complicated dynamic, where moments of connection were often overshadowed by bickering.

Storee persistently engages Cole, making small talk about his appearance, their shared history, and the deli menu. Despite his efforts to ignore her, Storee’s chatter gets under his skin, forcing Cole to leave the deli in frustration without his coveted chicken parm sandwich.

Chapter 3 Summary

Storee and Taran welcome their Aunt Cindy back home with a dinner of tomato bisque soup, but the evening quickly takes a surprising turn. Aunt Cindy, unexpectedly vibrant and mobile for someone recovering from a broken hip, arrives with her gossip-loving neighbors, Martha and Mae. Cindy, dressed in a cerulean-blue velour tracksuit matching the twins, shocks Storee with her liveliness, which contrasts with the frail image Storee had imagined.

As the dinner progresses, Cindy announces her plan to pass on her Christmas Kringle competition torch to Storee. The Christmas Kringle contest is an annual town tradition to crown the most festive person in Kringletown. Cindy, who has narrowly missed winning for years, has already submitted Storee’s application to compete, setting her up as her protégée. This announcement stuns Storee, who tries unsuccessfully to deflect the responsibility to her sister, Taran.

Taran firmly supports the idea, arguing that Storee’s participation is a way to honor Cindy’s efforts to create their magical Christmas memories over the years. However, Storee dreads the competition, haunted by a humiliating incident from a past town event where her clumsiness caused a series of mishaps, including a local woman falling into a river and needing a rescue.

Despite her protests, Storee realizes she may not have a choice. Cindy is adamant, and Taran emphasizes the importance of helping their aunt. The chapter ends with Storee reluctantly acknowledging the weight of the request and fearing the humiliation that might come with participating in the highly visible competition. The stage is set for Storee to confront her fears and navigate the challenges of representing her aunt in Kringletown’s most festive tradition.

Chapter 4 Summary

Cole is frustrated when his best friend, Max, informs him that Storee Taylor has entered the Christmas Kringle contest, a beloved Kringletown tradition. The competition determines the "merriest" person in town through festive challenges, sponsored by local businesses. Cole, a well-known grump who avoids the Christmas cheer, is particularly irritated that Storee—who once expressed disdain for the town—has decided to participate.

Max teases Cole about his growing irritation, suspecting it has to do with unresolved feelings for Storee. Despite Cole's protests that he doesn’t care, he can’t stop fixating on the idea of Storee trying to claim the Christmas Kringle title. He recalls a painful memory from the night his parents died: Storee unknowingly vented her dislike for Kringletown to him while he was grieving, a moment that solidified his resentment.

As Max continues to poke fun at him, Cole has a sudden, bold idea: he will enter the Christmas Kringle contest himself. His goal is to challenge Storee and prevent her from winning, believing she doesn’t deserve the honor. Max initially dismisses the plan, pointing out that Cole is the least likely person to win a contest focused on holiday spirit and jolliness. However, Cole is determined, listing the various tasks involved—like the Eggnog Wars, fruitcake baking, and public caroling—and insisting he can tackle them.

Cole reflects on how much the Christmas season has changed for him since his parents’ death. While the Maxheimer family has filled the void, the magic and warmth of the holiday feel like a distant memory. This realization deepens his resolve to participate. Moved by his friend’s vulnerability, Max reluctantly agrees to join the competition as Cole’s sidekick. Together, they commit to taking the contest seriously, setting the stage for a head-to-head showdown with Storee.

Chapter 5 Summary

Storee finds herself sitting in Aunt Cindy's overly floral bedroom as her aunt—recovering from her hip injury—proclaims her determination to mentor Storee for the Christmas Kringle competition. Aunt Cindy, despite her occasional feeble act, is sharp and focused on the task ahead. She insists that Storee embrace the competition fully, encouraging her to “jump in feet first” and reminding her that it's not just about winning but also about stepping out of her comfort zone.

Taran, meanwhile, continues playing the role of the perfect caretaker, attending to Aunt Cindy with unwavering dedication. Storee, feeling slightly overlooked, reflects on her reluctance to participate and recounts her embarrassment about her past mishaps in Kringletown. Aunt Cindy, however, brushes aside those memories, reminding Storee that the competition represents Kringletown’s highest honor and that she was chosen because of her creative spirit—something Taran, with her rigid and practical nature, lacks.

As Aunt Cindy speaks, she shares her perspective on life and regrets, explaining how important it is to embrace opportunities and create meaningful memories. She encourages Storee to avoid living a small, complacent life, reflecting on the cherished Christmas memories they once shared when Storee was younger. Aunt Cindy believes those moments shouldn’t just live in the past; they must be celebrated and passed forward.

Her words strike a chord with Storee, who realizes that she has been coasting through life—working, isolating herself, and avoiding experiences outside her comfort zone. Inspired by her aunt’s wisdom and moved by the thought of honoring the joyful memories they once created together, Storee begins to reconsider her reluctance. The chapter closes with Storee agreeing to take the Christmas Kringle competition seriously, determined to give it her best effort with Aunt Cindy’s guidance.

Chapter 6 Summary

The Christmas Kringle competition officially begins as the town of Kringle gathers in Ornament Park to hear Bob Krampus announce this year’s contestants. Cole and Max attend with a single-minded focus: to stop Storee Taylor from winning. Cole is uncharacteristically competitive, determined to protect the town’s Christmas spirit and prevent Storee—who he believes doesn’t deserve it—from earning the coveted title.

Bob Krampus reveals the five competitors: Jimmy Short, Ursula Kronk (the previous winner), Dr. Beatrice Pedigree, Cole Black, and finally, Storee Taylor, representing her Aunt Cindy. Storee’s inclusion immediately reignites tension between her and Cole. On stage, Storee’s friendly demeanor irritates Cole further, especially when Max playfully stirs the pot by introducing himself to Storee and teasing Cole. Storee mocks Cole’s grumpiness, and their banter—filled with sarcasm and jabs—continues throughout the event.

Bob and Sylvia Krampus invite the contestants into their storybook-style house for an orientation. Bob emphasizes the importance of embodying the Christmas spirit, introduces competition rules, and hands out gold sashes that all contestants must wear in public. The sashes, complete with fringe and pom-poms, symbolize their role as representatives of Kringle’s festive tradition. Sylvia warns that town “spies” will report on their holiday cheer, adding another layer of pressure.

After the meeting, Max orchestrates an awkward moment by insisting Cole walk Storee home. The pair bicker the entire way back, exchanging insults and escalating their rivalry. Cole accuses Storee of not caring about the town, while Storee counters that Cole is unnecessarily grumpy and rude. Their competitive tension reaches a breaking point, with each vowing to defeat the other in the contest. Storee mocks Cole by calling him “Connor” once again, driving him to declare her as his number one enemy.

Chapter 7 Summary

The day of the Eggnog Wars arrives, and both Storee and Cole are hard at work preparing their recipes for the first competition of the Christmas Kringle. At Aunt Cindy's insistence, Storee starts with an over-the-top ginger-heavy eggnog that turns out disastrously. After gagging on the drink, Storee convinces Aunt Cindy to switch to a trusted recipe card, which includes a more balanced mix of allspice, nutmeg, and other classic flavors. Aunt Cindy sends Storee to the Myrrh-cantile to pick up more ingredients, emphasizing that they need to perfect their recipe to win.

Meanwhile, Cole and Max are also at the Myrrh-cantile, debating their approach. Cole argues for a traditional eggnog, believing that everyone loves classic flavors. However, Max reminds him that their judges, Frank and Thachary, are known for their unconventional cocktails at the town bar, suggesting that creativity might be the key to winning. While Cole struggles to embrace the holiday cheer—awkwardly offering Christmas greetings to passing shoppers—Max watches with amusement as Cole fumbles his attempts to appear festive.

At the Myrrh-cantile, Cole and Storee cross paths, escalating their ongoing rivalry. Their conversation is full of sharp, sarcastic insults disguised as friendly banter, each attempting to outdo the other. Storee grabs allspice, nutmeg, and a box of gingerbread cookies, clearly planning a creative twist for her eggnog. Cole, noticing her ingredients, begins to reconsider his strategy and decides he and Max must think outside the box to compete.

As Storee leaves, Max teases Cole for scoping out Storee's basket, while Cole insists she remains their "enemy number one." Determined to beat her, Cole declares that they need to elevate their eggnog with a unique spin. The chapter ends with both teams heading into the competition fully committed, tensions high, and a creative showdown on the horizon.

Chapter 8 Summary

The first event of the Christmas Kringle competition, the Eggnog Wars, begins as the contestants prepare their festive concoctions. Storee, donning a Christmas sweater overloaded with jingling bells and a velvet bow, heads to the event with Aunt Cindy and Taran. Aunt Cindy, determined to win, insists that Storee use her recipe while adding strategic charm to win over the judges.

As Storee leaves for the competition, she encounters Cole, who exudes Christmas charm in a simple yet well-put-together outfit, earning compliments from the town’s gossip queens, Martha and Mae. Aunt Cindy questions Storee about her rivalry with Cole, revealing that the town has a soft spot for him because he’s been grieving the loss of his parents, who died in a car accident a decade ago. Cindy warns that Cole will be a major threat, as the townspeople are rooting for him.

The competition takes place at Prancer’s Libations, a popular, upscale town bar. Cole, alongside his "holly jolly sidekick" Max, presents his eggnog: a dark chocolate hazelnut creation, complete with decorative pine sprigs and handcrafted mugs. Confident that their drink will win on merit and presentation alone, Cole avoids gimmicks, determined to beat Storee fairly.

Storee, however, leverages Aunt Cindy’s involvement, presenting her gingerbread-inspired eggnog with rimmed glasses coated in crushed gingerbread cookies. Aunt Cindy dramatically plays up her frailty, slumped in her wheelchair to evoke sympathy from the crowd and judges. The move proves successful, and when the winners are announced, Storee takes first place, much to Cole’s irritation.

Despite his frustration, Cole forces a smile and congratulates Storee, though he inwardly fumes at her tactics. He realizes that if Storee and Aunt Cindy are willing to pull every trick in the book, he’ll need to step up his game to compete. As the chapter ends, Cole resolves to match their strategy with a renewed determination to dominate the competition.

Chapter 9 Summary

Storee wakes up riding the high of winning the Eggnog Wars and feels more determined than ever to dominate the Christmas Kringle competition. At breakfast, Aunt Cindy and Taran tease her about how much she enjoyed beating Cole. Storee admits she loved the victory but reminds them they need to stay focused for the next event: the Upcycle Christmas competition.

Aunt Cindy unveils her “Kringle Board,” an elaborate display tracking the competitors, events, and judges, complete with strings and notes. She explains that the upcycling challenge, judged by Sherry Conrad, involves creating a live-action scene from a favorite Christmas movie using recycled or upcycled materials. Aunt Cindy, the reigning champion from last year, proposes that they reuse her previous setup—Judy Garland’s iconic “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas” scene. Storee would perform while Aunt Cindy plays up her frail appearance to garner sympathy. Confident in their strategy, they celebrate their plan, feeling closer as a family and more determined to win.

Meanwhile, Cole and Max regroup at Cole’s house, frustrated by their loss in the Eggnog Wars. Max takes charge, presenting a detailed strategy that includes a poster board of the judges, complete with their personalities and preferences, and a list of holiday greetings for Cole to practice while interacting with townspeople. Max emphasizes the need to win the judges’ favor strategically, recognizing that Storee and Aunt Cindy will use every trick they can, including Aunt Cindy’s exaggerated frailty.

For the Upcycle Christmas event, Max pitches a bold and humorous plan: recreating a scene from The Grinch with Cole playing the Grinch himself. He reveals lederhosen inspired by the Jim Carrey version of the film, suggesting they lean into humor and spectacle to win over Sherry Conrad, who is a fan of both The Grinch and Thunder from Down Under. Cole flatly refuses, but Max remains determined to convince him.

Both teams prepare for the next competition, escalating their rivalry and setting the stage for a creative showdown.

Chapter 10 Summary

The Upcycle Christmas competition begins, and Storee prepares nervously for her performance. Dressed as Judy Garland from Meet Me in St. Louis, she recreates the iconic “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas” scene using Aunt Cindy’s props from the previous year. Taran ensures every detail is perfect, from Storee’s hair to the stage setup. Aunt Cindy plays her part by dramatically appearing frail and bundled in blankets, adding emotional weight to the scene. Despite her stage fright, Storee nails the performance, drawing tears from the crowd as snow gently falls, adding to the magic. The loud cheers and emotional reactions signal that Storee and Aunt Cindy’s plan was a success.

However, the mood shifts when Cole and Max appear, taking a vastly different approach. Dressed as the Grinch and his dog Max, Cole shocks the crowd with his unconventional performance. Shirtless and painted green, Cole wears lederhosen and fully embraces his role, tossing clothes around the stage in a humorous nod to The Grinch. Max’s antics as the loyal “dog” add to the spectacle. The performance culminates with Cole delivering a bold and unexpected pelvic thrust, sending the crowd into a frenzy. Sherry Conrad, the judge, is visibly enthralled, while the audience roars with laughter and cheers.

Backstage, Storee watches Cole’s antics with disbelief, annoyed that his over-the-top, comedic display contrasts so sharply with her heartfelt performance. Cole, on the other hand, is riding an adrenaline high, convinced his performance secured the win by appealing directly to the judge’s sense of humor and “weakness” for shirtless men. Max celebrates with Cole, marveling at the crowd’s wild reaction and declaring it a “cosmic boom.”

Chapter 11 Summary

The Upcycle Christmas competition has concluded, and Storee is fuming over Cole’s unexpected win. While Storee’s heartfelt performance, featuring a touching moment with Aunt Cindy, was meant to tug at the crowd’s emotions, Cole and Max’s comedic, shirtless Grinch performance—complete with lederhosen and a pelvic thrust—stole the show. Storee is frustrated, believing Cole’s victory was cheap and undeserved, especially since it relied on spectacle rather than sentiment.

As Storee vents to Aunt Cindy and Taran, they point out that Cole’s unexpected performance worked because it shocked the crowd. Aunt Cindy even admits to being “mesmerized” by Cole’s antics, much to Storee’s disbelief. Still, Aunt Cindy rallies the team, reminding them that the next event—Light Display—is crucial, as it’s historically been their weakest category. Aunt Cindy reveals that Cole used to help her with lights in past years, though she never leaned on him too much. Storee realizes Cole may have an advantage, but she’s determined to win.

Storee begins brainstorming for the light display, emphasizing the need for something flashy to stand out. While Taran agrees to help, Storee decides to snoop around to gather ideas. She heads outside to “spy” on Cole’s property but finds no signs of preparation. Just as she’s planning her next move, Cole catches her snooping. Their playful but competitive banter escalates as Cole teases her about losing the Upcycle event and claiming that his “stacked abs” gave him the win.

Frustrated and flustered by Cole’s confidence, Storee denies being impressed by his performance, though her choice of words betrays her. The two bicker all the way toward the hardware store, where they both seem to be headed—presumably to gather supplies for the Light Display. Their rivalry grows more intense, as both remain determined to outshine the other in the next competition.

Chapter 12 Summary

Storee remains flustered and frustrated after Cole and Max's surprise win in the Upcycle Christmas competition. Determined to beat them in the next challenge—the Light Display—she sneaks around Cole’s house and backyard to spy on his plans. Cole catches her snooping and, delighted by her antics, teases her relentlessly. Their competitive banter escalates, with Cole smugly pretending he’s planning to use a fifty-foot inflatable Santa as the centerpiece of his display, fully aware it’s against competition rules. Storee, convinced she overheard valuable intel, rushes home to share the “scoop” with Aunt Cindy and Taran.

Back at Aunt Cindy’s, Storee confidently relays Cole’s plan, but her family quickly points out that inflatable decorations are banned in the competition, highlighting that Cole likely tricked her. Storee realizes she’s been duped and is furious at herself for falling into his trap. The group regathers to strategize, with Taran meticulously measuring the house for lights while Storee insists they need something bigger and flashier to stand out. Aunt Cindy warns against rushing the display, but Storee remains adamant.

Later, as they begin work on the house, Cole appears to gloat, smugly commenting on their progress. Storee tries to play it cool but grows increasingly irritated by his confidence and teasing remarks. Their exchange takes a comedic turn when Martha and Mae appear, mistaking their heated banter for romantic tension. Cole, playing up the situation, wraps his arm around Storee and charms the twins, who gush over their “cute dynamic” and insist Cole is a good man trying to win her favor. Storee is left fuming, embarrassed that Cole manipulated the interaction to make himself look good.

As Cole departs, Storee vows revenge, though she can’t think of an immediate plan. Watching Cole and Max work efficiently on their own display, she realizes they are far ahead and insists to Taran that they need even more lights. With tensions running high and the rivalry heating up, Storee prepares for a showdown in the Light Display competition, determined to outshine Cole no matter what.

Chapter 13 Summary

Storee is panicked about their light display, believing Taran's "clean and simple" approach with twenty boxes of lights is too plain to win the competition. Cole’s house, impressively lit and styled like a giant present with a bow of lights on the roof, only amplifies her anxiety. Storee is certain they’re going to lose, but Aunt Cindy offers a solution: if Cole is playing dirty, they can too.

Following Aunt Cindy’s suggestion, Storee embarks on a sneaky mission to sabotage Cole’s display. Dressed in all black with her winter gear, she navigates the snow-covered yard, sneaks through the gate, and makes her way to Cole’s lights. After fumbling with frozen fingers and enduring multiple mishaps—including a face-first fall into a bush—she manages to unscrew a single lightbulb, causing a strand of lights to go out. Just as Peach and Paula, the judges, approach Cole’s house, Storee flees back through the snow and into Aunt Cindy’s yard, undetected but bruised and frostbitten.

Meanwhile, Cole and Max discover the malfunction and notice suspicious disturbances in the snow. Realizing someone tampered with their lights, they quickly deduce that Storee is the culprit. Furious, Cole decides to confront her. Cole and Max storm over to Aunt Cindy’s house, where they find Storee looking comically bedraggled—wrapped in blankets with her feet in a bucket of water and an ice pack on her head. Storee feigns innocence, denying any involvement despite Cole’s accusations. The argument escalates, with both accusing the other of playing dirty while Max attempts to mediate.

As tensions flare, Cole reveals that Max let slip about his childhood crush on Storee, which only fuels her teasing. Frustrated, Cole storms out, but not before yanking down a strand of lights from Aunt Cindy’s front door, signaling the start of a full-out rivalry. Both sides prepare to escalate their tactics as the competition heats up.

Chapter 14 Summary

Cole is furious after placing fourth in the Light Display competition, which he blames on Storee’s sabotage. While Max points out they’re still in first place overall, with Ursula close behind in second, Cole remains fixated on revenge and declares that they’ll up their game for the upcoming Fruitcake Festivus bake-off. With Tanya, the judge, working at Warm Your Spirits, Cole and Max decide to gather intel and charm her into favoring their fruitcake.

When they arrive at the café, however, they find Storee and Taran already sweet-talking Tanya. Realizing the competition is ahead of them, Cole improvises. He flips the narrative, pretending to harbor a decade-long crush on Storee and making a public show of admiration. He plays up the role of the pining small-town boy, tucking a strand of Storee’s hair behind her ear and telling Tanya he sabotaged his own light display so Storee wouldn’t feel alone in last place. Max supports the act, adding drama about Cole’s unrequited affection. Tanya, swept up in the “romantic” story, pressures Storee to give Cole a chance.

Caught off guard, Storee agrees to a “date,” knowing she has no choice but to play along to save face and keep Tanya’s goodwill. Tanya eagerly suggests they attend the Cupid Christmas celebration, a festive town event full of mistletoe and romance, which further complicates Cole’s plan. While Cole feels the situation spiraling, Storee resolves to use the fake date to her advantage, determined not to let Cole win over the town.

Back at home, Storee prepares for the evening, reassuring her sister, Taran, that it’s all part of the competition strategy. Despite Taran’s concerns about Storee getting distracted by Cole, Storee insists the date is entirely fake and strictly for the sake of Aunt Cindy. She heads out to face Cole, ready for what promises to be an awkward but critical night in their escalating rivalry.

Chapter 15 Summary

Cole reluctantly prepares for his fake date with Storee, dressing carefully under Max’s watchful eye and encouragement to “charm the town.” When Cole arrives at Aunt Cindy’s house to pick Storee up, the banter begins immediately. Aunt Cindy playfully nudges Cole and Storee to be kind to each other, even suggesting they rekindle their former friendship. Storee, frustrated but determined to maintain the farce, heads out with Cole as they walk toward Krampus Court for the Cupid Christmas celebration.

The date kicks off with Cole taking Storee to Prancer’s Libations for mulled cider. He plays up his charming persona, keeping up appearances in front of the townsfolk while teasing Storee relentlessly. Storee begrudgingly plays along, even as Cole pretends they’re a couple for Tanya and others to see. Their sarcastic, competitive banter continues throughout the night, as they stroll under Kringle’s beautifully lit archways and through the festive vendor stalls. Despite their mutual annoyance, there’s undeniable chemistry as they banter and tease each other.

Tension escalates when Cole playfully claims to have sabotaged his own light display to spare Storee from last place, a remark that riles her up further. However, their dynamic shifts unexpectedly under a mistletoe archway when Cole, caught in the moment and under the watchful eyes of Martha and Mae, kisses Storee. The kiss, which begins light and playful, deepens for a fleeting moment, leaving both of them visibly rattled and confused by the unexpected spark.

As they recover from the kiss, neither can fully explain what just happened, though they quickly agree to continue their fake-dating narrative for the town. Walking back toward home, both Cole and Storee are left with lingering thoughts and mixed emotions, questioning what might lie beneath their rivalry.

Chapter 16 Summary

Cole and Max scramble to prepare for the Fruitcake Festivus bake-off, having repeatedly failed to bake an edible fruitcake. They decide to use maraschino cherries as a last-minute addition, scrapping Max’s mom’s original recipe. As they rush to gather supplies, Max presses Cole for details about his date with Storee, revealing that the town is buzzing about their kiss. Cole insists it meant nothing, brushing off the rumors, though his inner thoughts betray lingering feelings about the moment.

At the competition, Cole and Max find themselves stationed next to Storee and her team. The rivalry between Cole and Storee flares again, with playful insults and competitive jabs exchanged as they prepare their cakes. Storee confidently declares her fruitcake unbeatable, reminding Cole that Aunt Cindy won first place the previous year with the same recipe, which notably includes mashed potatoes. Cole, meanwhile, remains hopeful their new “tropical twist” with pineapple and cherries will stand out.

Tanya, the judge, brings her usual romantic enthusiasm to the event, doting on both teams and commenting on Cole’s “crush” on Storee. Cole leans into the narrative, playing up his role by hugging Storee and calling her “babe” in front of Tanya, much to Storee’s irritation. Despite her annoyance, Storee remains focused, confident that her fruitcake will win.

When the judging begins, Tanya praises Storee’s fruitcake for its perfect execution and heartwarming family recipe, awarding her first place. Cole and Max place third, with Tanya commending their creativity but pointing out that the abundance of pineapple gave their fruitcake a more tropical flavor than a Christmas one.

With Storee now leading the competition overall, she takes a moment to savor the victory, teasing Cole about his second-place standing. Their banter continues, with Cole playfully flirting and Storee insisting his behavior is “inappropriate.” The chapter ends with Tanya’s praise lingering, Cole begrudgingly admitting defeat, and the rivalry between the two growing even more intense.

Chapter 17 Summary

Storee reluctantly prepares to drive through a snowstorm to Clayton for a candy cane-making lesson, as her sister Taran insists it’s necessary for the upcoming Candy Cane Competition. Despite her protests and fear of driving in the snow, Storee sets off alone. As the snow intensifies, she pulls off the road for safety but accidentally drives into a pothole, leaving her car stuck. With no cell service and panic rising, she’s stranded until Cole miraculously appears in his truck.

Seeing her upset, Cole comforts Storee and helps her into his truck, where she breaks down, overwhelmed by relief. He soothes her, holding her close and assuring her that she’s safe. Their previously hostile dynamic softens as Cole’s concern shines through. Storee, grateful but surprised by his kindness, agrees to let him drive her to the candy cane lesson in Clayton.

During the drive, they share an unexpectedly heartfelt conversation. Cole opens up about why he had been so hostile when she first arrived in town, revealing a painful memory. On her last Christmas visit ten years ago, Cole had been dealing with the disappearance of his parents during a snowstorm. That same night, Storee unknowingly vented to him about how much she hated Kringle, leaving Cole hurt and feeling abandoned when she left town abruptly. Storee is devastated to hear this and apologizes profusely, admitting her selfishness. Both agree to let go of the past and move forward, acknowledging the genuine connection they once shared.

Arriving in Clayton, Cole and Storee are grouped together for the candy cane lesson, only to learn that Theodore Garvey, their instructor, refuses to provide hands-on teaching for Kringle contestants due to his rivalry with Chadwick’s Candy Shop. Left to figure things out on their own, Cole and Storee work together, their teamwork and banter flowing more easily than before. As they stir ingredients and navigate the process, Cole’s playful charm resurfaces, and Storee finds herself enjoying his company. Their relationship seems to be shifting as they tackle the challenge side by side, setting the stage for deeper understanding and potential growth between them.

Chapter 18 Summary

Storee and Cole continue their candy cane-making lesson together, working side by side to complete the complicated process. The task involves boiling sugar, pulling it on a hook until it turns white, and carefully layering and twisting red-and-white stripes into the signature candy cane shape. Despite the physical challenge, the two manage to create an impressive candy cane, surprising themselves with how well it turns out. Their teamwork and banter are lighthearted and easy, as Cole helps Storee through the difficult parts, occasionally teasing her about her efforts. For the first time, their dynamic feels cooperative rather than combative.

As they leave the class, Cole opens the truck door for Storee, a small gesture of kindness that she notices. Their conversation becomes more personal as Storee thanks Cole again for rescuing her from the snowstorm and driving her to the lesson. She tentatively asks if they’re “friends” now, reflecting the softer tone their relationship has taken. Cole deflects with humor, warning her not to call him “Snow Daddy,” a nickname she playfully uses to tease him.

On the drive back to Kringle, the two share genuine laughter and lighthearted conversation. Storee jokingly describes Christmas as “kinky,” pointing out traditions like mistletoe and candles. Cole, entertained, feels an unexpected sense of happiness and lightness that he hasn’t felt in years. He admits to enjoying her company, a confession that sparks further teasing from Storee but hints at the evolving connection between them.

Once back in Kringle, their dynamic shifts again. Cole offers Storee a thoughtful goodnight, but the moment feels anticlimactic. Despite their shared warmth during the day, both are unsure of how to move forward. Storee suggests they continue their “enemies-to-lovers” act for the town, maintaining the playful rivalry. As they part ways, Storee is left feeling unexpectedly disappointed, wishing for more but unsure of where they now stand.

Chapter 19 Summary

Cole sits on his porch reflecting on the day and his growing feelings for Storee, realizing that things between them have shifted. Just as he contemplates the unresolved tension, Storee appears with a thermos of hot cocoa, joining him on the porch to ease the awkwardness that lingered after their drive back from Clayton. She admits that Cole makes her nervous, a confession that surprises him and leads to a heartfelt exchange about their past.

The conversation quickly deepens as Storee opens up about how Cole was someone she admired growing up and how sitting on his porch talking to him had been her favorite part of visiting Kringle. Cole, in turn, admits that he always thought Storee was out of his league but secretly looked forward to her visits. Their candidness creates a warm, intimate moment, with both acknowledging the bond they once shared and how much it still lingers.

As the night continues, Storee teases Cole, prompting playful banter that evolves into flirtation. The connection between them becomes undeniable when Storee straddles Cole’s lap and kisses him. The kiss, filled with passion and mutual longing, leaves both of them breathless. Despite the heated moment, Cole pulls back, insisting that Storee deserves more than a rushed encounter. Storee respects his hesitation but doesn’t shy away from teasing him further, calling him “Snow Daddy,” much to his chagrin.

Cole walks Storee back to Aunt Cindy’s house, where they share another soft, lingering kiss before parting ways. Storee warns Cole that their growing connection won’t change the competition—she’s still determined to win. Cole playfully fires back, promising to come out on top. As Storee heads inside, she’s left smiling, the unresolved tension between them replaced by a sense of joy and possibility.

Chapter 20 Summary

After his kiss with Storee the night before, Cole finds himself unexpectedly eager to embrace the Christmas spirit—something he’s avoided for years. He heads to Evergreen Farm, surprising Max by asking for a Christmas tree. Max, stunned by the change, presses Cole for details about his growing connection with Storee. Cole reluctantly admits they shared a kiss and aired out their past feelings, and while he’s drawn to her, he’s hesitant about getting too close because Storee lives in California and might leave Kringle.

Max encourages Cole to take the chance, suggesting that Storee’s return could be the push Cole needs to break free of the grief that has kept him stuck for years. Despite his reservations, Cole feels a newfound determination to embrace change.

Returning home with the tree, Cole’s fears are triggered when he sees Storee and her family packing the car, worried she’s leaving. Taran quickly clarifies that she’s only taking Aunt Cindy to a doctor’s appointment in Golden, leaving Storee to hold down the fort. After some playful banter, Storee notices the Christmas tree in Cole’s truck and offers to help him decorate. Cole hesitates, admitting that his house is “preserved” in time since his parents’ passing. Storee gently reassures him, encouraging him not to be ashamed.

Inviting her inside for the first time, Cole reveals his home, frozen in the past with furniture covered in sheets and family photos still on display. Storee’s warmth and understanding ease his anxiety, and she admires the memories of his family, particularly the photos that reveal a younger, happier Cole. Moved by her presence, Cole takes a leap, asking Storee to help him decorate his house for Christmas—a significant step in breaking free from his grief and opening his home, and heart, to change.

Chapter 21 Summary

Storee and Cole spend the evening decorating Cole’s house for Christmas, a significant step for Cole as it’s the first time in years he’s embraced the holiday spirit. Together, they unpack decorations from the basement, including sentimental ornaments and linens that once belonged to Cole’s family. Cole shares memories of his parents, such as their tradition of playfully rearranging “misfit ornaments,” and Storee is touched by the love and heartache in his stories. After the tree is lit and the decorations are set, the two share a quiet moment eating pizza while admiring their work.

Storee reflects on her regrets about avoiding Kringle for years, realizing how much she missed the joy and warmth of the season. She opens up to Cole about shutting herself off after her embarrassing Christmas incident, and Cole comforts her, admitting that revisiting these decorations has brought him closer to his parents’ memory rather than causing him pain.

The evening becomes more intimate as Cole reveals a surprise dessert—eggnog and a tin of shortbread jam cookies. Their playful teasing turns flirtatious, particularly as they revisit the topic of their kiss under the mistletoe and the one they shared the night before. Banter turns to shared confessions, with both admitting they were nervous about their feelings for each other.

The cozy setting, lit by the tree and fireplace, deepens their connection. Storee straddles Cole’s lap, leading to a passionate makeout session that escalates with increasing intimacy. The chemistry between them is undeniable as they explore their attraction, with Cole focused on making Storee feel wanted and cared for. After an intense and intimate moment, Cole tenderly asks Storee to spend the night, to which she happily agrees, signaling a deepening of their relationship beyond rivalry or the competition.

Chapter 22 Summary

Storee and Cole share a deeply intimate night as their relationship takes a significant step forward. After decorating Cole’s house for Christmas and growing closer, they head upstairs to Cole’s attic bedroom, which has remained untouched since his teenage years. Cole expresses some insecurity about the unchanged space, but Storee reassures him that she understands his need to preserve the past as part of his grieving process.

The playful tone between them continues as Storee teases Cole about an old Miss Piggy poster hanging on his wall. Embarrassed, Cole removes it, revealing a hole in the wall from a long-ago outburst during high school. This lighthearted moment gives way to a more tender one as Storee admires Cole’s willingness to open up, both emotionally and physically.

Once they settle into Cole’s bed, the intimacy deepens. The two share heartfelt conversations about their pasts and their present feelings. Storee praises Cole for embracing the holiday spirit, acknowledging the progress he’s made, and Cole admits that Storee has brought new life into his previously dull and routine days. He shares how her presence has made him feel emotions he hadn’t experienced in years, from anger and determination to a renewed sense of connection and attraction.

The night escalates as they explore their passion for each other, sharing intense physical intimacy that reflects their emotional bond. Their chemistry is undeniable, and both surrender to the feelings that have been building between them. Afterward, as they hold each other, Storee playfully acknowledges that their relationship has changed, and Cole agrees, confirming that their rivalry has given way to something much deeper.

The chapter closes with a sense of warmth and contentment, signaling a turning point for Cole and Storee as they begin to fully embrace their connection, both in the present and with an openness to what the future may hold.

Chapter 23 Summary

Storee and Cole's growing relationship plays out through a series of playful, flirtatious, and deeply intimate text exchanges while they are unable to spend time together in person. With Aunt Cindy and Taran back, Storee is tied up with holiday preparations, leaving Cole frustrated and missing her. Their texts range from lighthearted banter to full-blown sexting, revealing their mutual desire and deepening connection.

Cole initiates the flirty exchange by teasing Storee about a hickey he left and requesting a picture of her candy-cane-themed turtleneck. Their conversation quickly turns cheeky, with Cole joking about nipple bells and adopting ridiculous nicknames like "Big Daddy Dick Dong" before settling on "Cole." They banter back and forth about their previous encounters, with Storee playfully referencing their night together and teasing Cole about his insatiable energy.

The texts shift into a more heated tone as they confess their attraction and desire for each other. Storee details what she loves about Cole—his hands, voice, chest, and abs—while Cole reciprocates, professing his addiction to her lips and eyes. The exchange intensifies as they share fantasies and admit to being turned on, culminating in both of them describing their arousal and mutual longing. Cole encourages Storee to touch herself, and they share a sensual moment despite being apart.

The next morning, their messages turn sweet and playful again. Cole wishes Storee good morning, and they discuss their daily plans, which include Cole caring for the reindeer at the farm and Storee being roped into preparations for the caroling competition. Their conversation lightens as they exchange personal details, such as favorite Christmas cookies, movies, and decorations, deepening their emotional connection.

Despite their physical separation, their texts reveal a growing intimacy, mixing humor, romance, and desire. The chapter highlights how their bond has shifted from rivalry to something far more meaningful and passionate, with both eagerly anticipating the next time they can be together.

Chapter 24 Summary

The Candy Cane Showdown begins with all contestants, including Storee, Cole, and their teams, gathered in the school gymnasium at their workstations. Cole is on edge, both because of the competition and his frustration at not being able to see Storee for two days. Max, Cole’s holly-jolly sidekick, tries to refocus Cole on winning, revealing that he privately took a candy cane-making lesson with Jefferson Chadwick, the competition’s judge, to gain an edge. Max is determined to prove Dwight Yokel, an old rival, wrong after some teasing about their third-place standing.

Storee arrives looking stunning, distracting Cole and escalating the tension. In front of others, they continue their playful rivalry, exchanging barbs while hiding their real feelings. Martha and Mae, the town’s gossip twins, intervene, further fueling the “couple” narrative by commenting on their chemistry. Cole publicly invites Storee to visit his reindeer farm after the event, a plan they quietly agree on to sneak some time together later.

As the competition begins, Storee struggles with pulling the sugar to turn it white, her hands exhausted from the effort. Cole quietly steps in to help, pulling the sugar alongside her until it’s ready, earning another round of “aww”s from the audience. Storee appreciates his help but has to keep up appearances with her sister, Taran, who remains skeptical of Cole’s intentions. Meanwhile, Cole and Max work on a red, green, and white triple-striped candy cane to showcase their skills.

The judging begins with Jefferson Chadwick inspecting each batch of candy canes, critiquing their technique and flavors. When the results are announced, Storee lands in third place for her traditional candy cane but is marked down for not pulling the sugar herself. Cole and Max secure second place with their striped candy canes but miss out on first because they rejected Max’s earlier suggestion of pineapple flavoring. The surprise winner is Jimmy Short, whose bold pineapple-flavored candy canes impress Chadwick the most.

The chapter ends with Cole and Storee brushing arms, sharing a moment despite the rivalry. Atlas grumbles that he was right about the pineapple idea, and Cole begrudgingly admits, “You were right, dear,” as the competition wraps up. Both sides now look ahead to the remaining events, with their rivalry—and feelings—continuing to grow.

Chapter 25 Summary

After the Candy Cane Showdown, Cole takes Storee to Evergreen Farm for some much-needed time alone together. As Cole drives, they flirt and tease each other, with Storee admitting she’s been thinking about him constantly over the past two days. The playful energy continues when they arrive at the barn, where Cole introduces Storee to the reindeer. Each reindeer has a unique personality and backstory, revealing how much Cole cares about them and his work. Storee is charmed by Cole’s dedication and the way he lovingly talks about the animals, especially Rutabaga, a reindeer with a quirky habit of bowing after running in circles.

Inside the barn, their flirtation escalates into a passionate encounter. Cole ties Storee’s hands behind a wooden pole using leather reins, and the two explore their mutual desire in a heated moment of intimacy. Using a pineapple candy cane, Cole teases Storee, heightening the tension before they fully give in to their passion. The scene is filled with intensity, both physical and emotional, as they grow even closer.

Later, Cole takes Storee back to his house, where they continue to connect on a deeper level. They share peanut butter and jelly sandwiches in the kitchen before retreating to Cole’s room for a more tender and slow-paced night together. Their growing feelings are evident as Cole admits he wishes they’d reconnected sooner, reflecting on how Storee has brought life back into his days. Storee agrees, saying she’s enjoyed every moment with him.

However, when Cole suggests telling Taran the truth about their relationship, Storee hesitates, insisting they wait until the competition ends. She fears Taran’s reaction and doesn’t want to jeopardize their time together. Cole accepts her decision, but after Storee leaves, his friend Max expresses concern that Storee might be manipulating Cole to win the competition. Cole firmly dismisses the idea, confident in Storee’s sincerity.

Chapter 26 Summary

The Caroling Café competition arrives, marking the event Storee has dreaded most: singing and performing on stage. As she nervously prepares with Taran and Aunt Cindy, Storee feels overwhelmed, recalling her past embarrassing incident in Kringle. Taran remains firm, insisting Storee will succeed, while Aunt Cindy reassures her with lighthearted encouragement.

Meanwhile, Cole and Max prepare for their performance, with Max unveiling a heartfelt tribute: matching flannel shirts, a Santa hat, and a jingle bell necklace to honor Cole's parents. The gesture moves Cole, and he agrees, realizing it’s a meaningful way to reconnect with the memories of his family and embrace the Christmas season. Max, ever the comedic sidekick, lightens the mood with jokes, but he also supports Cole’s growth, recognizing how far his friend has come.

At the competition, Storee, Taran, and Aunt Cindy take the stage dressed in coordinated Santa-inspired outfits, performing a version of "Jingle Bell Rock" inspired by the Mean Girls dance. Storee’s initial nerves melt away as the crowd cheers and claps along. Taran’s comedic timing and Aunt Cindy’s walker-assisted “dancing” add charm to the routine, earning a strong reaction from the audience. Storee feels a surge of pride and relief as the performance ends to loud applause.

Cole and Max close the competition with a heartfelt rendition of "Blue Christmas". A picture of Cole and his late parents is projected behind them, emphasizing the emotional weight of the moment. Cole’s deep, soulful singing captivates the audience, and Atlas’s guitar accompaniment perfectly complements the performance. The tribute resonates with the crowd, leaving many teary-eyed, including Storee, who is moved by Cole’s vulnerability and the beautiful tribute to his parents.

When the results are announced, Cole and Max take first place, pushing Cole into the overall lead in the competition. Storee finishes third, with Jimmy Short’s "Carol of the Bells" guitar performance taking second. Despite her drop in ranking, Storee can’t help but feel pride for Cole’s success and growth. Their bond deepens further as they share a quiet moment backstage, with Cole asking her to come over later. Storee agrees to try, but Taran, oblivious to their relationship, pulls Storee away for “strategizing,” setting up the final stretch of the Christmas Kringle competition.

Chapter 27 Summary

Storee sneaks out of Aunt Cindy’s house late at night, determined to see Cole. Shivering in the cold without a jacket, she slips through the snow and makes her way to his house, where he welcomes her with hot chocolate and a warm blanket by the fire. Cole pulls her close, wrapping her in his arms as they settle on the couch, basking in the quiet comfort of the moment.

Storee praises Cole again for his heartfelt Blue Christmas performance, telling him how moved she was and how proud she feels. Cole opens up about how challenging the tribute was but also how important it felt to honor his parents. Their conversation shifts to playful teasing, with Storee comparing Cole’s voice to Hayes Farrow, a musician she admires, and Cole humorously fishing for compliments.

The lighthearted banter escalates into flirtation as they reminisce about their growing closeness and intimacy. Storee jokes about how she has brought “joy” back into Cole, while he teases her about her skills and compliments her beauty. The mood turns more sensual as Cole affectionately explores Storee’s body, taking his time teasing her and building anticipation.

Unable to resist their mutual desire, Storee sheds her clothes, and the two share an intense, passionate moment by the fire. Cole’s possessiveness and Storee’s willingness to surrender to him deepen their connection. Afterward, Storee confesses that no one has ever made her feel the way Cole does, and he echoes the sentiment, affirming their growing bond.

Chapter 28 Summary

Storee sneaks back into Aunt Cindy’s house early in the morning after spending the night with Cole. Her plan to return undetected is immediately foiled when Taran catches her at the front door. Flustered but quick-thinking, Storee invents a story about checking the snow and fabricates an accident involving her shoulder, successfully hiding the bite mark Cole left the night before. Taran eyes her suspiciously, sensing something is off, and questions why Storee suddenly seems so happy and eager to stay in Kringle. Storee brushes it off, claiming the town’s holiday spirit has grown on her.

As the tension eases, the sisters share a rare moment of connection. Taran opens up about feeling nostalgic and explains how much winning the Kringle competition means to Aunt Cindy, given her age and uncertain health. The conversation shifts to their parents, who are spending Christmas in Cancún, and both sisters express guilt about how their family has unintentionally neglected Aunt Cindy over the years. Storee suggests they make more of an effort in the future, hinting at the deeper bond she’s beginning to rediscover with her family.

Later, Storee meets Cole at Baubles and Wrappings, the local Christmas emporium. They explore the store together, exchanging flirtatious banter and playful jokes while shopping for gifts. Storee finds a rare American Girl doll, Felicity, in her holiday outfit—an item that would complete Aunt Cindy’s collection. Their outing is lighthearted, with Cole teasing Storee about the doll room where she’s been sleeping and sharing town gossip about the other competitors.

When Storee returns home, Taran pulls her into an intense practice session for the upcoming Super Santa Speed Round, critiquing Storee’s wrapping technique and stressing the importance of precision. Storee begrudgingly complies but feels torn, wishing she were back with Cole instead of being under Taran’s strict direction. She reassures them she has a plan for the stocking-making portion, promising a creative approach that might help them win.

Chapter 29 Summary

The final competition, the Super Santa Speed Round, kicks off in the gymnasium, transformed into a winter wonderland with stations set up for the contestants. Each Kringle-ee must complete three tasks: wrapping a present, crafting a Christmas card, and sewing a stocking. Storee, nervous but determined, is joined by Taran and Aunt Cindy, who offer repeated (and slightly overwhelming) reminders to focus on precision and technique.

As the competition begins, Storee notices Cole and Max arrive wearing ugly Christmas sweaters, looking both festive and annoyingly attractive. Cole and Storee exchange flirtatious barbs under the guise of rivalry, with Cole sneaking a whispered compliment to Storee about her beauty. Despite the tension and stakes, Storee feels her resolve waver as she finds herself distracted by Cole’s presence, particularly his surprising sewing skills.

Throughout the competition, contestants race to wrap, sew, and craft under pressure. Storee excels in wrapping and card-making but struggles with the stocking, accidentally sewing too close to the edge, which causes the felt to tear. She attempts to salvage it with a patch, but she knows it’s a noticeable flaw. Taran, from across the room, visibly groans in disappointment. Meanwhile, Ursula impresses with her expert wrapping but fumbles the stocking, while Beatrice opts for a blue-and-silver theme that doesn’t align with traditional Christmas aesthetics. Jimmy Short emerges as a surprise contender, producing an intricate, embroidered stocking that impresses the judges.

When the results are announced, Storee lands in third place, a disappointing finish that widens the points gap between her and Cole, who comes in second. Jimmy takes first place, celebrating with his ex-wife in the crowd, hinting at a possible reconciliation. Storee, feeling deflated, confides in Cole about her frustration and doubts. He reassures her that there’s still time to earn points, encouraging her to improve the light display before the final judging.

Chapter 30 Summary

The chapter begins with Cole and Max winding down after a family gathering, camped out on air mattresses at the Maxheimer house. As Cole debates whether to improve his Christmas light display, he reveals to Max that he’s conflicted about competing against Storee. Seeing her upset after the Super Santa Speed Round has left him torn, and Cole admits he’d rather see her win than himself. Max, frustrated and fully invested in the competition, urges Cole not to give up, reminding him of their efforts and commitment. Reluctantly, Cole agrees, promising to finish the contest strong.

Meanwhile, Taran lies awake at Aunt Cindy’s house, piecing together clues about Storee’s suspicious behavior. Remembering the late-night incident where Storee snuck back inside, the mark on her neck, and her frequent “strolls” into town, Taran deduces that Storee has been secretly seeing Cole. Worse, Taran begins to believe Cole is sabotaging Storee to win the Kringle competition. She recounts how Storee’s performance faltered after Cole started “helping” her and grows convinced that Cole is manipulating her sister’s feelings to secure his victory.

Furious and determined to protect both Storee and Aunt Cindy’s chances, Taran hatches a plan. In the dead of night, she sneaks out of the house armed with pliers and a hammer, ready to take revenge. Taran systematically dismantles Cole’s Christmas light display, removing every bulb, wire, and decoration from his house. With malicious satisfaction, she tosses the stolen lights into the trash, convinced she’s delivering justice for what she believes to be Cole’s betrayal.

The chapter ends with Taran returning to the house, confident that her sabotage will ruin Cole’s chances of winning the competition and restore Storee’s shot at claiming the Kringle title. All the while, Kringletown remains asleep, unaware of the destruction Taran has wrought under the cover of darkness.

Chapter 31 Summary

Cole and Max return to Cole’s house, ready to improve their light display before the final judging. However, they arrive to a shocking scene: every single Christmas light and decoration has been stripped from the house. Cole is stunned as they discover footprints leading directly to Aunt Cindy’s house, leaving little doubt about the culprit. Max speculates that Storee sabotaged Cole to ensure her own win, but Cole, though hurt and reluctant to believe it, begins to question Storee’s sincerity. Angry and feeling betrayed, Cole storms to Aunt Cindy’s house with Max in tow.

Confronting Storee at the front door, Cole accuses her of using him and tearing down his lights to sabotage his chances in the competition. Confused and hurt, Storee denies any involvement, but Cole refuses to listen, overwhelmed by the belief that she played him. His harsh words leave Storee shattered as he storms off, shutting her out completely.

Devastated, Storee learns the truth: Taran is the one who sabotaged Cole’s display, believing Cole was manipulating Storee to gain an advantage. Taran confesses she took down the lights to protect Storee and Aunt Cindy’s chances in the competition. Furious, Storee berates Taran, explaining that her relationship with Cole was real and accusing her sister of ruining something deeply meaningful. Determined to make things right, Storee heads outside, retrieves the discarded lights from Cole’s trash cans, and begins untangling them.

Realizing she can’t fix this alone, Storee enlists the help of Martha and Mae, begging them to rally the town to restore Cole’s lights before the judges arrive. As the neighborhood mobilizes, Storee feels both guilt and resolve, determined to show Cole she would never betray him. Alone in the bathroom afterward, she reflects on her love for Cole and fears he may never forgive her. Aunt Cindy reassures Storee that her plan will work, offering a sliver of hope that Cole will see the truth and forgive her.

Chapter 32 Summary

Cole isolates himself in the reindeer barn after confronting Storee, overwhelmed with hurt and betrayal. Haunted by memories of their time together, he wrestles with the thought that Storee used him and sabotaged his chances in the competition. Unable to return home, Cole decides to hide away, vowing to retreat from the holiday season once again.

Meanwhile, Storee enlists the help of the entire town to fix the damage done by Taran, who admits to taking down Cole’s lights in an attempt to protect Storee. Storee, heartbroken and determined to make things right, rallies neighbors like Martha, Mae, Jimmy, and even Ursula to restore Cole’s decorations. The community bands together, working tirelessly to string up lights and decorations around his house.

Afterward, Storee confronts Taran about her actions, and the sisters finally share an honest, heartfelt conversation. Taran apologizes for her lack of emotional availability, admitting she didn’t realize how lonely Storee had been. Aunt Cindy also confesses her own scheme—she faked her injury to bring the sisters closer together. While shocked, Storee and Taran acknowledge their need to reconnect as a family and commit to supporting each other moving forward.

As evening falls, Max drives Cole back to Whistler Lane under the pretense of visiting his house. Instead, Cole discovers his home fully restored, lit brightly with Christmas lights and filled with singing neighbors. At the center of it all is Storee, shivering in the cold but resolute to prove her love. She explains everything, revealing Taran’s actions and her own unwavering feelings for Cole. Storee confesses that she loves him, describing how their connection has made her feel alive and at peace.

Cole, moved by her words, admits that he loves her too. He acknowledges how Storee helped him rediscover joy and the memories of his parents, breaking through the grief he carried for years. Under the glow of the restored lights, Cole pulls Storee into a kiss, and the two embrace, united at last.

Ready for your next book?

We value your thoughts! Reach out with any feedback or requests regarding our selection of books. We're here to help and listen.

Email Requests

robjob4311@gmail.com